Jesus is not "separate" from the Father.
JESUS is GOD.
The Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit are the same Being, co-substantial and co equal, meaning One in nature, One in essence.
They are not three gods (tri-theism) or one Person "playing" three Persons (modalism). That is a contradiction and heresy.
If Jesus is GOD, is Jesus praying to Himself when He prays to the Father?
No.
Look at passages of Scripture like
John 20:17,
Matthew 27:46 cf.
Psalm 22:1, and similar verses (
John 17:1 through 5).
Consider this:
GOD is "the GOD of all flesh," see
Jeremiah 32:27.
The Father did not come down in the flesh, Jesus did, "and the WORD became flesh" (
John 1:14).
The Father is the GOD of His flesh. That's why Jesus can say "in His flesh" that He has a GOD over Him, not that Jesus is a separate god or that He is not GOD in the same sense the Father is.
Jesus submits to the Father by His HUMANITY that the Father is His GOD.
That is the context of passages like
John 20:17.
Jesus submits to the Father as His GOD but just because the head of Christ is GOD the Father that does NOT take away from Jesus having the same divine nature as the Father.
Just like, if the head of the woman is the man (
1 Corinthians 11:3), are they not both human?
Jesus humbles Himself to the Father. He is subordinate to the Father willfully but that does NOT take away that He Himself shares the same divine eternal nature as the Father as we see what the Scripture says, "For by Him ALL THINGS were created..." (
Colossians 1:16).
Was Jesus created?
If one says yes, then they would have to say that the Father created Jesus through Jesus (
John 1:3) and that makes no sense.
Why would Jesus refer to the Father as His GOD?
Because, again, you go back to the prologue in
John 1, where we are told the WORD, who is Jesus (
Rev. 19:13 cf.
John 1:1), became "flesh" (
John 1:14), that is relevant because of Jeremiah 32:27:
27 "Behold, I am the LORD, the GOD of ALL FLESH. Is anything too hard for me?"
Jeremiah 32:27
Since Jesus is distinct (not separate) from the Father and the Holy Spirit though One GOD with them...
Jesus became flesh in order to fulfill the Father's will because what did He say in John 6:38:
38 "For I have come down from heaven, not to do My own will but the will of Him who sent Me."
John 6:38
Jesus came down voluntarily to become flesh (
Hebrews 2:14 "partakers of flesh...") to take a status of a Servant (
Philippians 2:6 through 8) to fulfill My Father's will.
If Jesus became flesh and He is not the only Person who is GOD and the Father remains in heaven in His glorious state, and GOD is Spirit by nature, the Father didn't become flesh but the Son became flesh, should it shock us or surprise us that from the moment Jesus became flesh that the Father would become His GOD?
No.
I would have to expect that if the Bible is consistent.
So the answer to passages like
John 20:17 is that Jesus had a GOD over Him, namely the Father because Jesus became flesh, a flesh and blood human being and "the LORD [is] the GOD of all flesh" (
Jeremiah 32:27).
If one gets the deity of Christ wrong, i. e. Muslims, Jehovah Witnesses, Mormons, etc. that creates all sorts of problems when it comes to the question. "Who is Jesus?"
Jesus is not the Father:
16 "And yet if I judge, my judgment is true: for I am not alone, but I AND THE FATHER that sent Me."
John 8:16
The Holy Spirit is not the Father:
26 "But the Comforter, which is the Holy Ghost, whom the Father WILL SEND in My name, He shall teach you ALL things, and bring ALL things to your remembrance, whatsoever I have said unto you."
John 14:26
The Holy Spirit is not Jesus:
26 "But when the Comforter is come, whom I WILL SEND unto you FROM THE FATHER, even the SPIRIT of TRUTH, which PROCEEDETH FROM THE FATHER, He shall testify of Me:"
John 15:26
The Father is GOD:
Matthew 6:9,
Matthew 6:32;
John 4:23; 6:27;
Romans 1:7;
1 Corinthians 8:6;
Hebrews 12:9; et al.
The Son is GOD:
Exodus 3:14 cf.
John 8:58,
Isaiah 42:8 cf.
John 17:5;
Isaiah 44:6 cf.
Revelation 2:8;
Mark 14:62;
Hebrews 1:8;
Titus 2:13;
Romans 9:5;
Philippians 2:6; et al.
The Holy Spirit is GOD:
Genesis 1:2,
Psalm 139:7 through 12;
Acts 5:3 through 4;
1 Corinthians 2:10 through 11;
2 Corinthians 13:14;
Romans 8:26 through 27;
Titus 3:5 through 7; et al.
Our GOD is One Being, in Three distinct Persons. 1x1x1=3 or 1³
GOD bless you.
Dean Navarro